Will Atherton, a Clinical Canine Behaviourist from England, recently sparked a heated debate after calling the Springer Spaniel a “terrible choice” for most people. In a TikTok video, Atherton explained that while these dogs are often chosen for their appearance—often matching stylish accessories like a barber jacket for Instagram photos—many owners overlook what the breed was originally bred for: hunting.
According to Atherton, Springer Spaniels are bred to work tirelessly, “non-stop like frenzied lunatics,” which means they’re not typically the type of dog that enjoys lounging on the sofa. This constant energy, Atherton notes, can lead to “problem behaviors” when they don’t get enough stimulation, which is why he sees many Springers at his behavior center.
However, Springer Spaniel owners quickly voiced their disagreement.
“My springer is probably the laziest dog I’ve ever had.”
“My springer just sleeps most of the time.”
“Mine is either running around like a lunatic or just chilling, it’s great.”
“My Springer just wants to cuddle once at home, even though he’s a lunatic outside. I love him.”
“My Springer is both active outside and chilled at home.”
“We had a Springer growing up. He was active but so friendly and great with kids. I loved him.”
While the American Kennel Club (AKC) acknowledges that Springer Spaniels were bred for “long days in the field,” they also highlight the breed’s intelligence, trainability, and affection, making them great companions for families and good with other dogs. The AKC advises providing mental stimulation along with physical exercise, as otherwise, these dogs may find their own (sometimes less-than-ideal) activities to occupy their time.
Atherton’s comments, though divisive, serve as a valuable reminder of the importance of researching dog breeds before bringing one into your home. Studies have shown that certain traits are passed down through generations, particularly in purebred dogs, and those innate behaviors might not suit every lifestyle.
On the other hand, research also suggests that a dog’s environment can have a major impact on its personality, meaning early training and socialization can help shape a more balanced dog.
Ultimately, each dog is an individual with its own personality, but understanding the natural instincts of a breed before making a commitment can help ensure a better life for both pet and owner.