7 1

Why We Should Separate Thanksgiving from American History

Thanksgiving is a holiday deeply ingrained in American culture, celebrated annually with family gatherings, feasts, and traditions. However, the historical context surrounding Thanksgiving is complex and often controversial. Many historians and advocates argue that it is time to reconsider the holiday's association with American history and its narratives, particularly in light of the experiences of Indigenous peoples. 

Here’s a look at why we should separate Thanksgiving from American history and reconsider the way we celebrate it.

1. Misrepresentation of Historical Events

The commonly told story of Thanksgiving often simplifies or distorts the events of 1621, when English Pilgrims supposedly shared a feast with the Wampanoag people. This narrative presents an idealized version of cooperation and harmony between two cultures. In reality, the arrival of the Pilgrims marked the beginning of a long history of conflict, colonization, and violence against Indigenous peoples. By maintaining this simplified narrative, we overlook the significant struggles and injustices faced by Native communities.

2. Cultural Appropriation and Insensitivity

Thanksgiving can be seen as an example of cultural appropriation, where aspects of Indigenous culture are co-opted and commodified by non-Indigenous people. The holiday often features symbols and traditions—such as the turkey, cornucopias, and the image of Native Americans in feathered headdresses—that do not accurately represent the diverse cultures of Indigenous peoples. By continuing to celebrate Thanksgiving in its current form, we risk perpetuating stereotypes and diminishing the rich histories and identities of Native communities.

3. Acknowledgment of Indigenous Struggles

Separating Thanksgiving from American history allows us to create space for a more nuanced understanding of the ongoing struggles faced by Indigenous peoples. The impact of colonization has had lasting effects, including loss of land, cultural erasure, and systemic inequities. Instead of celebrating a holiday that glosses over these realities, we could redirect our focus toward acknowledging the historical and contemporary injustices faced by Native communities. This shift could promote healing, awareness, and respect for Indigenous rights.

4. Opportunity for Alternative Celebrations

By decoupling Thanksgiving from its historical context, we open the door to alternative celebrations that honor Indigenous cultures and promote awareness. For instance, many people now participate in National Day of Mourning on Thanksgiving Day, which honors the lives and histories of Indigenous peoples and recognizes the ongoing impacts of colonization. This day encourages reflection, education, and solidarity with Native communities, allowing for a more meaningful observance that contrasts sharply with traditional Thanksgiving festivities.

5. Encouraging Critical Conversations

Separating Thanksgiving from American history encourages critical conversations about the complexities of our nation’s past. It challenges us to question who gets to tell the story of America and how those narratives are shaped. By engaging in discussions about the realities of colonization, cultural representation, and Indigenous rights, we can foster greater understanding and empathy among individuals from diverse backgrounds.

6. Emphasizing Gratitude Beyond Tradition

Thanksgiving is often framed around themes of gratitude and togetherness. However, these values do not have to be tied to a specific historical narrative. We can cultivate gratitude and appreciation for one another and the world around us without relying on a holiday rooted in a problematic history. By focusing on personal reflections and community connections, we can create new traditions that align with our values while honoring the diversity of experiences that exist in our society.

Conclusion

As society continues to evolve, it’s essential to reevaluate our traditions and their implications. Separating Thanksgiving from American history allows us to acknowledge the complexities of our past, honor the voices of Indigenous peoples, and create more inclusive practices moving forward. This change doesn’t mean erasing the holiday altogether but rather transforming it into an opportunity for reflection, education, and meaningful connection. By fostering a deeper understanding of our history and the experiences of all Americans, we can create a more respectful and inclusive society.

Scroll to Top